| The trend towards outsourcing will continue | | | | temporary agency, or similar entity |
| to grow as market pressures force | | | | |
| corporations to be more tightly focused on | | | | is not a guarantee against misclassification |
| core business functions, gaining competitive | | | | under the joint employer rule applied by the |
| advantage and reducing costs. Outsourcing is | | | | |
| an attractive alternative in good times and | | | | Ninth Cir. Court in Microsoft III. If a |
| bad times. Shifting back end administrative | | | | misclassification does occur a firm may |
| and business functions to an external | | | | qualify for |
| provider in good times, may be a means for | | | | |
| quicker time to market and focusing resources | | | | an IRS Section 530 "safe harbor" exception |
| on core business activities to grow the | | | | if it can show the following:1. Reasonable |
| business. In bad times, outsourcing is a | | | | basis for classification of individuals as |
| means for streamlining the enterprise by | | | | ICs based on:- Reliance on a relevant court |
| eliminating functions, which create a drag on | | | | case, the advice of a qualified accountant or |
| capital and/or do not provide any competitive | | | | attorney, |
| advantage.In the current economic | | | | |
| environment, concerns over, shrinking | | | | or IRS ruling;- The IRS did not reclassify |
| margins, liquidity and the | | | | the same or similar workers in a previous |
| | | | audit;- It is standard industry practice to |
| need to reduce operating cost structures is | | | | treat the particular workers as ICs.2. |
| accelerating a trend towards shifting certain | | | | Consistently treated same or similar workers |
| | | | as ICs in the past.3. Consistently filed |
| back office administrative functions to | | | | federal tax forms 1099 on these same or |
| outside suppliers. This trend is seen as a | | | | similar workers.Outsourcing any critical |
| major | | | | business function and especially one like HR |
| | | | must be carefully |
| paradigm shift within enterprises, which | | | | |
| have realigned their internal corporate | | | | planned and executed to be an economic and |
| | | | strategic success. HR operations require |
| infrastructure to focus on more strategic | | | | |
| areas of their core business.Although the | | | | trained and specialized personnel to handle |
| human resources (HR) function is viewed as | | | | complex processes and manage the |
| critical within corporations, | | | | |
| | | | compliance responsibilities created under |
| increasingly, small, medium and even large | | | | the myriad of federal and state employment |
| corporations are moving to outsource this | | | | |
| | | | regulations. Outsourcing of this function |
| service.The case for outsourcing has three | | | | carries the risk of losing qualified |
| basic rationales. First the regulatory | | | | personnel and |
| | | | |
| compliance obligations imposed under ERISA, | | | | a degradation of the function. A firm can |
| COBRA and IRS regulations, have | | | | ill afford the risk of entering into a |
| | | | relationship |
| become extremely burdensome and expensive | | | | |
| for companies. Consequently, avoiding | | | | with a vendor whose lack of expertise in |
| | | | payroll and benefit administration causes |
| major legal problems and financial liability | | | | |
| requires substantial investment in resources | | | | disruptions and a loss of efficiency. This |
| | | | may, in the worst case, demoralize the work |
| and capital in an area outside of the core | | | | |
| business of most companies. This makes | | | | force and expose the firm to significant |
| | | | legal liability. Partial success in this area |
| outsourcing a viable option even if it does | | | | can |
| not necessarily result in a cost savings in | | | | |
| the | | | | mean total failure and the loss of strategic |
| | | | initiative.Contracting of the outsource |
| near term. Second, the need to upgrade HR | | | | service is a process which requires inputs |
| systems and invest in new technology is | | | | from all of the |
| | | | |
| increasingly difficult when companies are | | | | stakeholders (HR personnel, users of the |
| hard pressed to invest in functions aligned | | | | service, and the management team) and those |
| with | | | | |
| | | | persons within or outside of the |
| the core competency of the enterprise. HR | | | | organization with expertise in the function. |
| outsourcing service providers are better | | | | Before talks |
| | | | |
| positioned to invest in new technologies and | | | | are ever initiated with a vendor, the key |
| software more likely to conform to "best | | | | goal is to define the scope of the service |
| | | | and the |
| practices" for delivery of the service. | | | | |
| Third, for companies with global operations, | | | | performance metrics, which will be applied |
| | | | to measure success. The use of metrics will |
| employee self-service can substantially | | | | |
| reduce costs and improve employee | | | | be covered in greater detail below in |
| satisfaction | | | | respect to Service Level Agreements |
| | | | (SLAs).Important to both parties in the |
| with the service. However, this requires | | | | transaction, is defining the kind of |
| integration of all processes- HRIS, payroll | | | | relationship, which |
| and | | | | |
| | | | must be established for the arrangement to |
| benefits administration- across the entire | | | | succeed. If the entire HR Dept function is to |
| HR operation including its global | | | | |
| ones.Because of the business exigencies | | | | be outsourced then it will be in the |
| driving the shift towards HR outsourcing, the | | | | interest of both parties to enter into a |
| industry | | | | long-term |
| | | | |
| is expected to grow to $37.7 Billion in | | | | relationship that will justify the up-front |
| 2003. | | | | costs and investments that will be required |
| | | | of |
| Currently HR outsourcing services fall | | | | |
| primarily within three categories: | | | | each of them. This type of arrangement as |
| Professional | | | | previously mentioned is subject to the firms |
| | | | |
| Employer Organization (PEO), Business | | | | particular circumstances, and will probably |
| Processing Outsourcing (BPO) and Application | | | | result in selecting either the BPO or PEO |
| | | | |
| Service Providers (ASPs).4 | | | | alternative because of the broad scope of |
| | | | the outsourced service. For the buyer this |
| PEOs assume and take full responsibility for | | | | type |
| the human resources administration, | | | | |
| | | | of wholesale delegation is expensive, |
| including the legal liability for the | | | | complex and risky. If it doesn't work out, |
| company's workers. It becomes in essence a | | | | the |
| coemployer | | | | |
| | | | buyers will incur significant costs and, |
| with final say over, hiring, firing, and | | | | disruption to the business in replacing the |
| compensation decisions. The PEO | | | | vendor |
| | | | |
| becomes a partner, in the non-legal sense, | | | | or in bringing the function back |
| with ownership of the HR function while the | | | | in-house.Typically, total outsourcing of a |
| | | | function is a major undertaking with broad |
| company retains responsibility over all | | | | implications |
| business matters.BPO refers to all business | | | | |
| processes and not just HR. Typically this | | | | for both the buyer and vendor. In this |
| involves transferring | | | | situation the preferred relationship is one |
| | | | that is |
| the entire function to a service provider | | | | |
| and is differentiated from PEOs because it | | | | more of a partnership, in the non-legal |
| | | | sense, where the parties view their interests |
| usually involves introducing new | | | | as |
| technologies and processes to bear in the HR | | | | |
| service. | | | | mutually benefited by the relationship.On |
| | | | the other end of the continuum is the |
| Because of the complexity of HR systems in | | | | outsourcing of processes, like payroll, which |
| large corporations, shifting to BPO may be | | | | is |
| | | | |
| more expensive in the short term. However, | | | | very specific and straightforward and can be |
| long term it can result in benefits because | | | | executed on a short-term basis. |
| | | | |
| large HR outsource providers will invest in | | | | Normally, in the HR area, firms will retain |
| systems and technology viewed as | | | | part of the function in-house, and delegate |
| | | | |
| prohibitively expensive within a firm where | | | | those functions to an ASP or BPO, which |
| this function lies outside of its core | | | | require major investments in technology or |
| business.The BPO services market is growing | | | | |
| rapidly with analyst projecting revenues of | | | | software. An outside supplier whose core |
| $128 | | | | compency lies within function is better able |
| | | | to |
| billion this year and growth to $234 billion | | | | |
| by 2005.Finally, ASPs host software on the | | | | absorb the costs, based on economies of |
| web and rent it to users. The most commonly | | | | scale. This type of arrangement will |
| known | | | | generally |
| | | | |
| of these packages is "People Soft". The | | | | result in an intermediate term relationship |
| latter application and other packages are | | | | where the parties will have to develop close |
| used to | | | | |
| | | | collaboration but will not have to incur the |
| manage payroll, benefits, head count and | | | | high costs, and investment of resources |
| other HR processes.Each of the HR outsourcing | | | | |
| services described has advantages and | | | | required in a long-term |
| disadvantages for | | | | relationship.Partnership arrangements require |
| | | | provisions that maximize the flexibility of |
| particular enterprises depending, on the | | | | the vendor in |
| number of employees, affordability of the | | | | |
| | | | performing the service. Typically because |
| service, type of business and the degree to | | | | such relationships are appropriate in |
| which an enterprise desires to retain control | | | | contracts |
| of | | | | |
| | | | with long terms of duration, typically five |
| this function in-house.This paper will | | | | to seven years, and complex service |
| briefly cover the legal aspects of HR | | | | |
| outsourcing and will discuss some | | | | arrangements, the approach ought to be less |
| | | | prescriptive with respect to the scope and |
| of the most common contract issues faced in | | | | |
| outsourcing relationships, essential items | | | | level of service. |
| | | | |
| that ought to be considered by the parties | | | | In shorter-term arrangements more typical of |
| and key provisions within outsourcing service | | | | supplier/purchaser relationships, contracts |
| | | | |
| agreements.As previously discussed, | | | | need to be more prescriptive in defining the |
| companies facing pressure to reduce costs or | | | | scope of the services and the client |
| address the | | | | |
| | | | requirements.Generally contracts ought to |
| personnel shortages due to corporate down | | | | build in some level of flexibility to allow |
| sizing have several different outsourcing | | | | for changes in:business circumstances, |
| | | | |
| alternatives available to them to delegate | | | | technology |
| back-end administrative functions. Typically, | | | | |
| | | | and the needs of the buyer.Transfer of |
| the first alternative firms look to before | | | | Personnel and Assets:Outsourcing arrangements |
| looking outside, is to retain control of the | | | | may require the transfer of assets and |
| | | | personnel to the vendor. |
| function in-house and reduce employment | | | | |
| related costs (taxes, benefits, headcount), | | | | Defining the terms covering the transfer of |
| by | | | | affected personnel will generally have |
| | | | |
| using contingent staff or (temporary | | | | important implications for the buyer and its |
| workers) or persons classified as | | | | employees with respect to employment or |
| "independent | | | | |
| | | | employment rights. When wholesale |
| contractors" (IC) to perform the work. | | | | outsourcing of groups or functions occur, it |
| Though this may be an appealing solution for | | | | is |
| | | | |
| many firms, given the legal and economic | | | | important for firms to take measures to |
| benefits, improper classification of someone | | | | preserve the general morale, of those |
| as | | | | remaining |
| | | | |
| an IC, consultant or temporary worker, who | | | | and communicate openly and honestly with |
| is later deemed an "employee" carries | | | | those persons transferred under the |
| | | | |
| serious financial risks.Friction has | | | | outsourcing agreement. Contract terms need |
| developed between the growing use of contract | | | | to address how the outsourcing of the |
| workers in lieu of full time | | | | |
| | | | function and subsequent transfer will affect |
| employees and, the public policy aims of | | | | benefits, pensions and pay of personnel |
| providing workers with protections under | | | | |
| | | | moved to the service provider. Consideration |
| federal labor laws to take the Employment | | | | should also be given to the rights, if any, |
| Retirement Income Security Act ("ERISA") | | | | |
| | | | the transferring firm may have to either |
| and state law employee remedial measures. In | | | | enforce special terms affecting transferred |
| addition to the tax risk of an IRS audit, the | | | | |
| | | | employees or the right to retain these |
| risks are higher today that workers will | | | | employees in the event of contract |
| bring claims for social security, workman's | | | | termination. |
| | | | |
| compensation or other actions challenging | | | | With respect to equipment and other assets, |
| the misclassification, so that they may | | | | terms governing the use by the vendor of any |
| | | | |
| participate in lucrative benefit programs | | | | equipment made available to it by the buyer |
| provided by the employer. | | | | should specify rights of ownership and other |
| | | | |
| The case that brought these issues to the | | | | matters related to the transfer of equipment |
| fore was Vizcaino v. Microsoft Corporation | | | | or other items of value.Defining the rights |
| | | | to intellectual property (IP) is critical in |
| ("Microsoft I") and its progeny of cases. In | | | | all outsourcing agreements. |
| Microsoft I, plaintiffs, employees designated | | | | |
| | | | Typically the vendor will want to retain |
| as temporary workers or "free lancers", | | | | rights in any IP developed by it in the |
| brought an action against the corporation to | | | | course of |
| | | | |
| recover savings benefits under ERISA and for | | | | the arrangement. The thought being that it |
| stock option benefits offered through a | | | | is providing a service and not being paid to |
| | | | |
| stock purchase plan, that were available to | | | | develop IP. The buyer on the other hand will |
| regular employees.6 The Court framed the | | | | want all rights to IP developed based on the |
| | | | |
| legal and public policy issues in the | | | | transfer of proprietary or confidential |
| opinion's opening statement: | | | | information to the vendor and any work |
| | | | product |
| "Large corporations have increasingly | | | | |
| adopted the practice of hiring temporary | | | | developed in performing the service. This |
| employees or | | | | issue will usually be resolved through |
| | | | |
| independent contractors as a means of | | | | negotiation. |
| avoiding payment of employee benefits, and | | | | |
| thereby | | | | Related to this are confidentiality |
| | | | provisions, which provide important |
| increasing their profits. This practice has | | | | contractual |
| understandably led to a number of problems, | | | | |
| legal and | | | | protections with respect to each party's |
| | | | right's in and use of IP in the |
| otherwise. One of the legal issues that | | | | arrangement.Services |
| sometimes arises is exemplified in this | | | | |
| lawsuit. The named | | | | This is will probably be set out in a |
| | | | schedule and negotiated based on the scope of |
| plaintiffs, who were classified by Microsoft | | | | the |
| as independent contractors seek to strip that | | | | |
| label of | | | | services and the functions or processes that |
| | | | will be outsourced. As stated previously, the |
| its protective covering to obtain for | | | | |
| themselves certain benefits that the company | | | | nature of the relationship, partnership or |
| provided to all of | | | | supplier/purchaser will determine how |
| | | | detailed |
| its regular or permanent employees."The | | | | |
| problems for Microsoft arose as a result of | | | | and specific this ought to be.In any event |
| an IRS tax audit for tax years 1989 and | | | | there should be sufficient clarity and |
| | | | definition for the parties to be able to |
| 1990. The IRS examined the company's | | | | |
| employment records to determine if it was in | | | | set mutual expectations and understand the |
| | | | deliverables that must be produced under the |
| compliance with tax laws. Applying the | | | | |
| common-law principles defining the | | | | agreement. |
| employer-employee relationship, the IRS | | | | |
| concluded Mircosoft's "freelancers" were not | | | | Termination |
| | | | |
| independent contractors but employees for | | | | Defining the terms for exiting an |
| withholding and tax purposes. | | | | arrangement is one of the most critical |
| | | | issues in an |
| In reaching this conclusion, the IRS applied | | | | |
| the test set out under the common law of | | | | outsource agreement. Generally, early |
| | | | termination provisions, which set out rights |
| agency, which requires, in determining if a | | | | and |
| hired party is an "employee", consideration | | | | |
| of | | | | applicable penalties due in such event, |
| | | | should be a matter of last resort except in |
| the hiring party's right to control the | | | | cases, of |
| manner and means by which the product is | | | | |
| | | | material breach or force majeure.Default |
| accomplished. The IRS applies a 20 factor | | | | provisions should set out escalation clauses |
| "control test" to "assess all of the | | | | and a reasonable cure period to |
| incidents | | | | |
| | | | ensure the parties have procedures for |
| of the relationship" with no one factor | | | | resolving disputes and issues related to the |
| being determinative of the employment | | | | |
| | | | performance of their respective obligations. |
| relationship of the parties.9 The US Supreme | | | | |
| Court reached asimilion conclusion in | | | | There should also be provisions governing |
| | | | the management of the exit. These should |
| Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company vs. | | | | |
| Darden party not to adopt the IRS factors | | | | include the vendor cooperation in |
| | | | facilitating the transfer of the service to |
| and, instead applied a twelve factors that | | | | another vendor |
| it considered. In assessing the relationship | | | | |
| of | | | | and the return of any equipment or other |
| | | | items to the buyer, which were used by vendor |
| the parties the court decided for | | | | |
| determining whether an individual qualifies | | | | during the contract. |
| as a | | | | |
| | | | Consideration should be given to other |
| "common law employee".Microsoft, on first | | | | provisions, which might help to reduce the |
| impression, appeared to have taken the | | | | level |
| appropriate measures to avoid | | | | |
| | | | of disruption to the buyer's operations as a |
| stumbling into an employer-employee | | | | result of the termination of the |
| relationship- the workers were told they were | | | | agreement.What is a Service Level Agreement |
| | | | (SLA)?SLAs in an outsourcing arrangement |
| freelancers and signed various agreements | | | | identify the service levels or performance |
| classifying them as independent contractors, | | | | standards |
| | | | |
| that included provisions that the workers | | | | that the vendor must meet or exceed. The SLA |
| would be responsible for paying their own | | | | also specifies consequences for failing to |
| taxes | | | | |
| | | | achieve the minimum service level set by the |
| and benefits. However, after having taken | | | | buyer. |
| these steps with respect to the form of the | | | | |
| | | | SLAs should be applied to the key parts of |
| relationship, the court found that Microsoft | | | | the outsourced service and not necessarily to |
| had fully integrated these workers into its | | | | |
| | | | every aspect. The purpose of SLAs is to |
| workforce, placing them alongside regular | | | | ensure the buyer has the means to control the |
| employees, sharing the same supervisors, | | | | |
| | | | level and the consistency of the service |
| performing identical functions and working | | | | received from the provider. |
| the same core hours. Because Microsoft | | | | |
| | | | Generally, the minimum level that ought to |
| required them to work on site, they were | | | | be set is that which is required to support |
| given admittance keys, office equipment and | | | | the |
| | | | |
| supplies of the company.Even after the IRS | | | | buyer's on-going business operations and HR |
| determined that plaintiffs were "common law | | | | requirements. An important rationale for |
| employees", Microsoft | | | | |
| | | | outsourcing should be to improve the level |
| attempted to use a temporary agency to | | | | and quality of the function that is being |
| "house" these workers as employees of the | | | | |
| | | | outsourced. Therefore the minimum level of |
| agency, so that it could continue to use | | | | service should be at least equal to the level |
| them in the same manner previously described. | | | | |
| | | | that existed before the function was |
| On review in Vizcaino v. U.S. Dist. Court | | | | outsourced to the provider. |
| for Western District of Washington, 173 F.3d | | | | |
| | | | In the HR area metrics are difficult to |
| 713 (9th Cir. 1999) ("Microsoft III"), the | | | | establish because much of what is being |
| Court in striking down the District Court's | | | | measured |
| | | | |
| modification of the class of plaintiffs, | | | | is intangible. For example if buyer wants to |
| which it deemed a contravention of its order | | | | determine the success of a web based |
| on | | | | |
| | | | application for benefits, this can only be |
| remand, rejected the lower court's assertion | | | | ascertained by surveying user satisfaction. |
| that the eligibility for benefits of these | | | | As |
| | | | |
| temporary agency workers turned on whether | | | | such questionnaires and employee |
| they were employees of the Company or | | | | satisfaction surveys become essential tools |
| | | | for |
| the agency. The District Court's view | | | | |
| precluded the possibility that the agency and | | | | measuring the performance of the vendor.SLAS |
| | | | must reflect the agreement understanding of |
| Microsoft could jointly employ the | | | | the parties as to what constitutes a |
| plaintiff. The Court held that at common law | | | | |
| it was | | | | good result and with respect to measuring |
| | | | performance, their agreement on the |
| possible for the plaintiff's to be employees | | | | |
| of both the temporary agency and of the | | | | mechanisms used to measure the result. |
| | | | |
| recipient of their services (Microsoft), if, | | | | The SLA should also cover what constitutes |
| based on a determination using the Darden | | | | the best and the worst-case level of service. |
| | | | |
| factors, an employee-employer relationship | | | | In this regard the buyer will want to |
| existed. In essence the agency and Microsoft | | | | incorporate service credits, which may become |
| | | | |
| were joint employers and the triangular | | | | applicable in the event the vendor fails to |
| relationship that Microsoft created was not | | | | meet minimum service levels. At the same time |
| | | | |
| viewed as precluding or as being mutually | | | | it is also appropriate to consider |
| exclusive of a two- party relationship that | | | | incentives or bonuses, which the vendor can |
| | | | receive for |
| existed between the company and the | | | | |
| temporary workers. So what are the lessons | | | | achieving the best-case level of service.The |
| gleaned from the Microsoft cases?- Review the | | | | point of any negotiation ought to be that it |
| language in the company's benefit plans to | | | | is in the interest of both parties that the |
| ensure "covered | | | | |
| | | | vendor meet or exceed the service levels set |
| employees" is properly defined within the | | | | in the SLA. The buyers should not exploit |
| plan and not left to statutory or judicial | | | | |
| | | | the use of SLAs, to reduce costs through the |
| interpretation.- The mere classification of | | | | application of credits or penalties, because |
| workers as independent contractors is not | | | | |
| sufficient, | | | | this will only inject an unnecessary level |
| | | | of contention into the relationship that will |
| and behavioral, financial and the type of | | | | |
| relationship between the hiring party and | | | | under cut the development of a partnership |
| | | | between the parties. |
| the workers must support the | | | | |
| classification.- Users of outsourcing | | | | SLAs should not have a distorting effect on |
| services should apply the 20 IRS factors to | | | | behavior, where the vendor becomes focused |
| conduct a selfassessment | | | | |
| | | | only on those aspects of the service, that |
| of the relationship between the parties.- | | | | are measured, at the expense of other |
| Consider using only ICs that are incorporated | | | | aspects, |
| so that the relationship is between | | | | |
| | | | which may not be weighted as heavily in the |
| entities and not an individual and an | | | | evaluation process. The vendor's goal |
| entity.- Ensure that the agreement reflects | | | | |
| the 20 factors, so for example: allow the IC | | | | should be to meet, or exceed expectations in |
| to | | | | every area covered by service.Born in Havana, |
| | | | Cuba, Mr. Rojas immigrated to the United |
| determine the means and the methods for | | | | States in 1961 and lived in Ohio and the U.S. |
| delivery, limit the agreement to the | | | | Virgin Islands before settling in Florida in |
| | | | 1967. He studied computer programming for |
| project, and ensure the contract calls for | | | | three years in a high school "magnet" program |
| the IC to cover its expenses and benefits.- | | | | and earned his B.A. in English and Philosophy |
| Require that the IC submit an invoice prior | | | | from the University of Florida in 1978, with |
| to receiving any payments.- Avoid placing IC | | | | honors in Philosophy. Mr. Rojas then attended |
| in situations where work is subject to the | | | | law school at the University of Miami where |
| direct supervision of a | | | | he received his J.D., with honors, in 1981. |
| | | | In law school, Mr. Rojas was an Articles and |
| company employee.- Avoid imposing | | | | Comments Editor of the school's International |
| administrative requirements on the IC, which | | | | Law Review and served as a member of the Moot |
| are applicable to | | | | Court Board.Mr. Rojas holds the highest |
| | | | ratings assigned by Martindale-Hubbell, and |
| employees.- Allow the IC to hire and | | | | he is listed in several "Who's Who" |
| delegate the work to its employees subject to | | | | publications including Marquis' Who's Who in |
| the | | | | American Law, Who's Who In Florida's Latin |
| | | | Community, Who's Who In Intellectual |
| requirements of the project.In particular, | | | | Property, and Who's Who in International |
| the fact that a worker is employed by a | | | | E-Commerce. He is fluent in Spanish. |